Reynolds was selected 23rd overall by the Bayhawks in the 2009 MLL Collegiate Draft. He has been a solid force for the Hawks, recording 22 goals, five assists, and 127 ground balls in 68 games.
Reynolds played college lacrosse at the University of Maryland where he tallyed 19 goals and three assists, totaling 22 points. He also logged 74 ground balls and 22 caused turnovers. Jeff was named to the All-ACC Academic Team, All-ACC Team, USILA Honorable Mention All-American, and Preseason Honorable Mention All-American.
Reynolds attended Calvert Hall in Baltimore, where he was 2nd Team All-Baltimore County and helped the Cardinals to the 2002 MIAA Championship. He was also a star running back and defensive back on the football team.
Reynolds is from Bel Air, MD, the son of Donald and Beverly Reynolds. He graduated from the University of Maryland in 2009 with a double major in International Business and Finance, and a GPA of 3.2. When Jeff is not playing lacrosse, he works full time as a Financial Advisor in Baltimore, and enjoys mountain biking or cycling in his free time.